Immigration White Paper: right rhetoric, but light on solutions

Responding to the Government’s new Immigration White Paper, CPS Research Director Karl Williams said:

‘The publication of today’s Immigration White Paper shows that the Labour Party has, finally, accepted the arguments put forward by the Centre for Policy Studies and others that migration is not an unmitigated economic good, that various visa routes such as the social care visa and the Graduate visa are too readily abused, and that data around the impact of migration is woefully inadequate and needs significant overhaul.

‘However, the measures proposed fall some way short of those actually required to get migration down to the kind of levels which the public would be happy with.

‘For example, cutting the time someone can stay in the UK on a Graduate visa from 24 months to 18 months will do nothing to address the problem of those using student and graduate visas to access the country with the primary intent to work, not to study, and then switching to other routes to extend their stay.

‘The Government has also acknowledged the enormous increase in family visas and difficulties in deported foreign offenders back to their home countries, yet the White Paper takes no decisive action on either issue – simply kicking the can down the road until at least the end of the year.

‘Ultimately the government has refused to commit to a numerical level of net migration. Our report ‘Taking Back Control’ proposed an annual migration cap, set by Parliament, with limits for each specific visa route. This would give democratic legitimacy to the immigration system and reassure the public. It is disappointing that the Government have so far refused to consider this option.’

ENDS

NOTES TO EDITORS

Date Added: Monday 12th May 2025