BUSINESS LEADERS NEED TO STEP UP FOR BRITAIN’S LOOMING BATTLE OF IDEAS
I’m delighted to be here addressing the Confederation of British Industry. My relationship with the CBI goes back a long way.
Back in the early 1990s, as a young think-tanker, I met then Director General Howard Davies, and did some research on a pamphlet he wrote called “Fighting Leviathan” – an essay on how to make the state more efficient.
As a journalist at The Financial Times in the late-1990s, and then as a Channel 4 News correspondent, I spent a lot of time talking to his successors Adair Turner and, subsequently, Digby Jones.
When Richard Lambert became Director General I knew him anyway – he was my former Editor at The Financial Times.
And now, spooling forward, I’m delighted to have been invited here by the CBI’s current CEO Rain Newton Smith, a fellow economist and someone I’d not only like to thank, but to congratulate for her leadership of the CBI over recent years.
Now the Bayeux Tapestry, of course, depicts the 1066 Norman conquest, the Battle of Hastings between King Harold and William of Normandy.
There is no such battle on UK soil today – indeed, 1066 was the last time this nation was successful invaded by a foreign army. But there is, I’d say, now a clear battle across British politics and our economy. A Battle of Ideas.
I’m a natural optimist – and remain convinced the UK remains a great place to live and work. We boast top universities and enormous scientific and artistic acumen.
And – crucially – Britain is home to some great businesses, including thousands of small- and medium-sized firms, run by talented, driven entrepreneurs.
But it strikes me that for quite a few years now, any economic and commercial success we have had in Britain has been despite rather than because of government policies.
For decades, under the Tories and now Labour, the state has been getting bigger – and is now far too intrusive and chronically unaffordable, to the extent that the size of the state is threatening our financial stability.
After the statism of the 1970s, the tax burden – tax revenue as a share of national income – fell steadily during the 1980s to around 30pc of GDP by 1990, the end of the Thatcher era.
The tax burden starting rise again under New Labour, most markedly after the 2008 financial crisis, and continued growing pretty steadily during 14 years of Tory-led government.
Over the last two years, according to the International Monetary Fund (IMF), since Labour took office in July 2024, Britain’s tax burden has risen faster than any major economy. We’re at around 38pc of GDP now – the highest tax burden since 1948 – heading for 42pc, says the Fund, by the end of this decade. And that’s before this month’s budget.
Increasingly, the centre-left is pushing for higher taxes, more state borrowing and spending – bigger government. The centre-right, on the other hand, is increasingly backing lower taxes, government that does less, a smaller state.
This is the battle of ideas now looming over the British economy. Politics is about to get more stark, vivid and much more consequential.
And while journalists, think tanks and business lobby groups need to be pragmatic, of course, maintaining working relations, dealing with the government of the day, it strikes me that in this battle of ideas business leaders do need to stand up for what works, especially when the going gets tough, when the country we all love is going in the wrong direction.
When you look at the UK’s high inflation and still sluggish growth, when you look at our spiralling energy costs, rising unemployment and particularly our increasingly precarious public finances – with the UK paying more to borrow than any other major economy – we clearly are going in the wrong direction.
For years, Britain has lived beyond its means – with governments of all stripes spending way more than they’ve collected in tax. We’ve run just one annual surplus this century – and that was by accident, back in 2001, as a result of a 3G spectrum auction which raised a lot more money than expected. All parties of government are to blame.
The UK government borrowed £24.5 billion last month, according to new figures just released. Almost £11 billion of that went on debt interest payments – £400 per household on debt service costs, in September alone.
During this financial year, from April to September, the government’s debt interest payments amount to £61 billion – that’s our annual defence budget, enough to build 40 brand new state-of-the-art hospitals, or employ 100 thousand extra nurses for ten years.
£61 billion would pay for free-at-the-point of use social care for everyone who needs it in the UK, for an entire year – three times over.
That’s just six months’ debt service payments.
This isn’t how any of you would run a business. And it’s not how we should be running our country.
While this isn’t a battle with France, I often hear from MPs and ministers that our friends across the channel have a higher national debt than we do. Yes, but Britain’s national debt has been accumulating so quickly, and we’ve become so prone to inflation, that our debt services costs are now 3.6pc of GDP, compared to less than 2.5pc in France.
The UK’s public finances are dangerously precarious – serious people, including former senior Bank of England, Office for Budget Responsibility and IMF officials are now speaking out. I believe business leaders need to speak out too.
To end, seeing as we’re about to look at an astonishing battle scene, I wanted to say what this country means to me – and where my intense interest in economics and business springs from.
My late father, the eldest of five, came to the UK from the West of Ireland in his early teens. 1950s Britain was tough for the Irish, but he was smart and hard-working.
Martin Halligan built a construction business – never more than a dozen men and a few vans – almost getting wiped out during the policy madness of the mid-and late-1970s. That’s why I studied economics – because I saw the ghastly impact of bad economic policymaking on ordinary peoples’ lives.
Having grown up in a small business environment, I know where growth and prosperity come from. And before my Dad died last November, he told how grateful he was to Britain, while urging me to use my energy and contacts to influence economic policy more directly. That’s why I joined the Centre for Policy Studies.
The UK boasts some long-established organisations that rightly and honourable get heavily involved in our policy debate, as part of our broader democracy. We’ve got the CBI, of course, as well as the Institute of Directors. We’ve got a range of policy research institutions, such as the Institute of Fiscal Studies and the National Institute of Economic and Social Research, as well as think tanks of all colours like the Institute for Public Policy Research, the Resolution Foundation and, indeed, the CPS.
I do think that a battle of ideas is looming, that Britain is approaching a fork in the road, with the gap between parties widening, our political choices becoming more stark.
While that battle won’t be easy, let us hope it is conducted, to the extent it can be, with honesty, integrity and mutual respect.
Perhaps not quite as consequential as the Norman Invasion, it’s a battle that nonetheless matters intensely, not least as its outcome will significantly impact not just the UK’s national prosperity, but the lives and livelihoods of millions of British households.
So, Ladies and Gentlemen, let battle commence. And let us reflect, that as the ultimate creators of our national wealth, when it comes to that battle, Britain’s business leaders, of firms big and small, have a vital role to play.
A condensed version of this speech appeared in City AM.
Date Added: Wednesday 21st October 2026